ToM discussions thread

Post by **Trigger Happy** » Sat Jun 04, 2011 8:04 pm

ToM Rules wrote:... Though every track release outside of the (official/international T.H.) forums is for ToM like it wasn't released. ...

GRITA release or a position on GRITA's ToM (Tracciato del Mese) or elsewhere e.g. release on Polish forum or its own Polish ToM (which exist too) has no influence on this. And I remember well, this MaxGenerally's track never was released on any international forum, the nomination is valid.

Post by **Trigger Happy** » Mon Jun 06, 2011 12:05 pm

Out of that small issue above we have there few more problems this month. From nominations I skipped for now Svitavy by xmilek because it seems to be just minor update of very old track (just added people?). From same reason I very doubt about Bruno Asp's Velopark 2011. Is it enough update of the previous version to add it as nominees (it got 1 vote in summer 2010)? And GP Bahia 2009 by Bruno Asp because I think, that's same track like bit more detail 2010 version, which takes a part in the voting too (analogy to ToM rule about historic evolution packs). Do you think, that any of them should be added to the nominees, please?

After we'll solve this Buka can start the voting.

Bouncebackability · Post by **Bouncebackability** » Mon Jun 06, 2011 1:38 pm

trying to think of past examples of similar situations

imo, Bahia should be nominated as one track, not twice, i even thought at the time, why didnt he just put the tracks in the same topic.

if Svitavy is just an update it should be skipped as this is just the same principle as Black Rebels updates.

but Velopark, i dont know, its basically the same track, just with a new layout update, a small one at that, but it is more significant than just adding people/1.10 objects. if i was to choose one or the other, i would say allow it

http://forum.gene-rally.com/download/fi ... &mode=view
http://forum.gene-rally.com/download/fi ... &mode=view

a1b23 · Post by **a1b23** » Sat Jun 18, 2011 5:01 pm

does anyone else think the voting period is way to long?

Post by **Trigger Happy** » Sat Jun 18, 2011 6:17 pm

We had bit more complex nominations this months, so it delayed the start.

Otherwise it's 2 week for years AFAIK, in past it was starting closer to end of month, but we increased the gap to allow more time for nominations of tracks released in last few days of month, because they were in past very often missed in nomination list.

a1b23 · Post by **a1b23** » Sat Jun 18, 2011 6:53 pm

Trigger Happy wrote:We had bit more complex nominations this months, so it delayed the start.

Meaning what exactly?

Post by **Trigger Happy** » Sat Jun 18, 2011 6:58 pm

Read the 5 posts above your first. It takes few days to investigate it all and then to discuss it.

bduddy · Post by **bduddy** » Wed Jun 29, 2011 11:44 pm

I just noticed that some of the statistics on the ToM website appear to not be working...

felipebart · Post by **felipebart** » Thu Jun 30, 2011 12:47 am

Well, this month we don't have many tracks... But i'm seeing the last tracks posted, and I'm certainly that 60% of this tracks deserves a nomination

a1b23 · Post by **a1b23** » Sun Jul 17, 2011 6:37 pm

Has any Track every received 20 votes?
I'm only asking this since the stats page for this on the TOM website wont work.

Post by **Buka** » Sun Jul 17, 2011 8:37 pm

a1b23 wrote:Has any Track every received 20 votes?
I'm only asking this since the stats page for this on the TOM website wont work.

I don't think so. Someone should try to make such a track.

GeorgM · Post by **GeorgM** » Mon Jul 18, 2011 7:45 pm

Hey guys, I've repaired the stats. Have fun! ^^

Scholl · Post by **Scholl** » Thu Aug 04, 2011 9:26 am

Sorry for offtopic but:
Wouldn´t it be easier to simply nominate each track that was posted during the month?
I never got the point of this whole nomination progress....

BRIX · Post by **BRIX** » Thu Aug 04, 2011 9:52 am

Scholl wrote:Sorry for offtopic but:
Wouldn´t it be easier to simply nominate each track that was posted during the month?
I never got the point of this whole nomination progress....

But then it would be difficult to choose the best track among so many other tracks.

Areen · Post by **Areen** » Thu Aug 04, 2011 11:22 am

Scholl, I think not. Simply - nominations are needed, because they giving some "flow" for the track - it shows that some tracks are better than others. (it's good explanation? ;d)

Post by **Trigger Happy** » Thu Aug 04, 2011 11:30 am

This is right place for discussion, Scholl, not nomination topic.

Post by **Buka** » Fri Aug 05, 2011 8:33 am

Though Brix and Areen are right, I want to remind that you can vote any track even if it wasn't in a nominees list.

Post by **Trigger Happy** » Sun Aug 14, 2011 12:59 pm

@ Areen:

Buka wrote:When you nominate ... please never edit your nomination posts, as your changes could be overlooked.

Overlooked not just by ToM staff, but also by other people nominating tracks, so the editing can create confusions (multiple nominations of same track etc). Please, send the later nominations rather in new posts next time.

BTW thanks for one for Fionn Gorm.

Areen · Post by **Areen** » Sun Aug 14, 2011 2:59 pm

No problem. I didn't see any posts so I edited first to write more nominations. I don't like unnecessary spam.

My GeneRally 2 profile · Post by **TuomoH** » Mon Aug 15, 2011 11:16 am

MattyG wrote:
masto_pursi wrote:T Rallys by: MattyG
A&T Rallys

One can't nominate track packs in cases like your pack but only individual tracks.

MattyG · Post by **MattyG** » Mon Aug 15, 2011 11:27 am

Can i still vote for ZaishenCircuit By Zaekyr even though it says its a trackpack?

Post by **Trigger Happy** » Mon Aug 15, 2011 11:31 am

MattyG wrote:Can i still vote for ZaishenCircuit By Zaekyr even though it says its a trackpack?

ZaishenCircuit is no problem, it's only variations of one track. Nomination of your pack incorrect is. Unless he wanted to nominate just ''T'' Rally from the A&T pack.

masto_pursi · Post by **masto_pursi** » Mon Aug 15, 2011 11:51 am

minä en oikein ymmärrä

pitääkö minun muuttaa linkkiä

-----------------------
I do not really understand: D, do I have to change the link

:

My GeneRally 2 profile · Post by **TuomoH** » Mon Aug 15, 2011 12:09 pm

@masto_pursi: Jos halusit ehdottaa molempia ratoja, sun pitää mainita molempien nimet, mutta jos halusit ehdottaa vain T Rallya, on homma ok.

Explained the issue.

masto_pursi · Post by **masto_pursi** » Mon Aug 15, 2011 12:13 pm

ok that is, all is ok

ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: Track of the Month - July 2011 (nomination time)

Re: Track of the Month - July 2011 (nomination time)

Re: Track of the Month - July 2011 (nomination time)

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: ToM discussions thread

Re: Track of the Month - August 2011 (nomination time)

Re: Track of the Month - August 2011 (nomination time)

Re: Track of the Month - August 2011 (nomination time)

Re: Track of the Month - August 2011 (nomination time)

Re: Track of the Month - August 2011 (nomination time)

Re: Track of the Month - August 2011 (nomination time)

Re: Track of the Month - August 2011 (nomination time)

Re: Track of the Month - August 2011 (nomination time)